This popular spot, located in the heart of Key West, provides a memorable dining experience. Known for its outstanding service and delicious American cuisine, it's a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for groups seeking a great meal. Diners rave about the tender fish and flavorful dishes, with many calling it the best meal they've ever had. With attentive staff and a reputation for excellence, this restaurant offers an enjoyable experience at a mid-range price point.
This popular spot, located in the heart of Key West, provides a memorable dining experience. Known for its outstanding service and delicious American cuisine, it's a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for groups seeking a great meal. Diners rave about the tender fish and flavorful dishes, with many calling it the best meal they've ever had. With attentive staff and a reputation for excellence, this restaurant offers an enjoyable experience at a mid-range price point.
This popular spot, located in the heart of Key West, provides a memorable dining experience. Known for its outstanding service and delicious American cuisine, it's a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for groups seeking a great meal. Diners rave about the tender fish and flavorful dishes, with many calling it the best meal they've ever had. With attentive staff and a reputation for excellence, this restaurant offers an enjoyable experience at a mid-range price point.
Restaurant Analysis
This restaurant has been analyzed using our formula-based system to help you understand its key features and match it with your dining preferences.
Price Range (Moderate)
Moderate pricing ($$) - Mid-range restaurants with good value
Meal Time (lunch)
This restaurant primarily serves lunch. Based on opening hours.
Group Size (Groups Welcome)
Welcomes large groups and families. Great for group dining.
Atmosphere (Outdoor)
Al fresco dining with outdoor seating
Dining Style (Casual)
Walk-in friendly. No reservations needed. Casual dining experience.
Features & Amenities
This restaurant offers: Outdoor Seating, Cocktails, Beer, Wine, Coffee, Groups Welcome
Sourced from recent guest feedback and verified reviews.
Not to be dramatic but this is actually the best meal I’ve ever had. We had this place recommended to us by one of the crew members of Sebago and it absolutely did not disappoint. From the moment we sat down the service was incredible. Very kind and attentive staff. Our waitress was Samari (I hope that’s right) and she was absolutely wonderful, she walked us through everything and was above and beyond with service. The fish was so tender and the flavors were 10/10. I tried many different kind of...
Find the Restaurant
920 Caroline St, Key West, FL 33040, USA
Restaurant data powered by Google Places API
December 30, 2025
Not to be dramatic but this is actually the best meal I’ve ever had. We had this place recommended to us by one of the crew members of Sebago and it absolutely did not disappoint. From the moment we sat down the service was incredible. Very kind and attentive staff. Our waitress was Samari (I hope that’s right) and she was absolutely wonderful, she walked us through everything and was above and beyond with service. The fish was so tender and the flavors were 10/10. I tried many different kind of oysters, they were well worth it. I would recommend this place to anyone and everyone and we will definitely be back.
January 20, 2026
Love !!!! Pepita chicken yes please. Curry cauliflower was amazing. Skirt steak has no comparison. There's really no wrong choice. Ive been to 3 of their locations now and the consistency in service , food and cleanliness impressive. Our waitress this time was Kelsey and she is so sweet, very happy to answer questions. I'd happily eat here again. My only complaint is there is no changing table for littles in the bathrooms. (Picture of Short Rib special)
January 12, 2026
Yellow tail special Omg best fish and salad that I have ever had! Key lime pie freshly made , and coconut popcorn shrimp just wow ! Try local beer “Crazy Lady” a little light honey taste beer I love it
October 19, 2025
Went with the recommended snapper sandwich and fish special. Food was great! My one issue was that our server's heavy latin accent and VERY fast speech made it hard to understand everything she said. She was friendly and attentive, just needs to speak more slowly - especially for "old folks" like me and hubby. We'll return!
November 6, 2025
Our server Anton was wonderful! Everyone in the whole restaurant worked as a team to take care of every need! We had the calamari appetizer and it was fabulous! We both had the Conch schnitzel with the rocket salad, wonderful! Next time going to try the oysters, big selection and fresh!
Features and amenities that make Square Grouper special
Outdoor Seating
Cocktails
Beer
Wine
Coffee
Groups Welcome
Everything you need to know before you visit
Build your own culinary trail—save these spots for future nights out in Key West.
With a stellar 4.9-star rating, this Key West gem is a brunch lover's paradise! Fresh, flavorful dishes and a fun atmosphere await. Discover why everyone raves about this must-visit spot.
Discover the magic! This highly-rated Key West bistro (4.9 stars!) offers delicious food, live music & a fantastic atmosphere. Make a reservation and experience it for yourself!
Experience the buzz around this top-rated Key West gem! With a stellar 4.9-star rating, this spot is serving up delicious Cuban cuisine. Discover why it's a favorite – read the reviews and plan your visit!
Indulge your sweet tooth! This Key West dessert spot boasts a stellar 4.8-star rating. Sample decadent desserts & unique wine-based drinks. Reserve your table today and experience the magic!
Experience the buzz at this top-rated Key West gem! With a stellar 4.7 rating, this spot offers fresh, delicious dishes and amazing cocktails. Discover why it's a favorite – plan your visit today!
Rated 4.7 stars! Craving a delicious breakfast or brunch in Key West? Discover fresh juices, excellent coffee, and generous portions at this popular spot. Read reviews and plan your visit today!
Discover a Key West favorite! This highly-rated spot (4.7 stars!) offers delicious vegan & Mediterranean cuisine in a vibrant setting. Experience the charm – plan your visit today!
Rated 4.7 stars! Discover a Key West favorite. Enjoy American classics, breakfast delights, and a fun atmosphere at this popular spot. Plan your visit today!
With a stellar 4.7-star rating, this Key West gem offers fresh, satisfying seafood. Discover why diners rave about the lobster rolls and enjoy the casual atmosphere. Explore the menu today!
Discover La Grignote in Key West, a local favorite with a 4.7-star rating! Savor authentic French breakfast & baked goods in a charming atmosphere. Book your table and experience it today!
Rated 4.7 stars! Discover delicious seafood at this Key West gem. Enjoy fresh catches, a relaxed vibe, and island charm. Perfect for groups. Book your table today!
Rated 4.7 stars! Discover a Key West favorite. Enjoy incredible seafood & American fare in a unique ambiance. Make your reservation today and experience the magic!
Rated 4.7 stars! Craving authentic Cuban sandwiches and coffee in Key West? This popular spot is a local favorite. Discover why visitors rave about the food and atmosphere. Plan your visit today!
Experience Key West's top-rated beachfront restaurant! With a 4.7-star rating, this spot offers delicious seafood, live music, and stunning sunset views. Make a reservation and savor the flavors!
Experience exceptional dining at this highly-rated Key West restaurant! With a 4.7-star rating, diners rave about the incredible food and unique atmosphere. Make a reservation and discover your new favorite spot today!
Experience the buzz at this Key West favorite! Boasting a stellar 4.7-star rating, this spot offers delicious Cuban sandwiches and strong coffee. Ready for a taste of paradise?
Craving amazing pizza in Key West? With a stellar 4.7-star rating, this spot is a local favorite! Enjoy delicious wood-fired pizza and Italian favorites. Explore the menu and plan your visit today!
From transportation to stays, we help you build a complete itinerary around this must-visit restaurant in Key West.
Explore comprehensive guides to plan your perfect trip, including food tours, cultural experiences, and more.
Planning your trip to Key West? Key West International Airport (EYW) is the primary gateway for travelers arriving in this vibrant destination. You can easily compare a variety of airport transfer options, including shared and private services, to find the best fit for your travel needs. Booking in advance ensures a smooth transition from the airport to your accommodation.
Discover Key West's rich history and culture through its fascinating attractions and museums.
Explore the turquoise waters of Key West at your own pace with a boat rental.
Sail the turquoise waters of Key West and experience unforgettable ocean adventures.
Explore the turquoise waters and enjoy unforgettable experiences on a Key West day cruise.
Discover the vibrant marine life and unique ecosystems of the Florida Keys on guided eco-tours departing from Key West.
Savor the flavors of Key West with delectable food and drink tours.
Discover Key West's vibrant artistic soul and rich history on immersive walking tours, uncovering galleries, unique architecture, and local stories.
Explore Key West's vibrant culinary scene and discover delicious local flavors on guided food and drink tours.
Uncover Key West's chilling past with spine-tingling ghost tours, exploring its haunted streets, historic buildings, and eerie legends.
Immerse yourself in the captivating past of Key West, from pirates and poets to presidential visits, with expertly guided history tours.
Dive into the vibrant turquoise waters of Key West with thrilling and scenic water sports tours. Explore coral reefs, spot marine life, and soak up the Florida Keys sunshine.
Discover the unique flora and fauna of Key West with these unforgettable tours.
Explore the latest and greatest tours and activities Key West has to offer!
Explore the vibrant waters surrounding Key West with unforgettable boat tours and activities.
Discover Key West's beauty with professional photo shoots tailored to your style.
Indulge in exclusive Key West adventures with personalized service and premium amenities.
Discover the beauty of Key West from the deck of a sailboat with unforgettable experiences.
Discover the best seasonal experiences Key West has to offer, from festivals to sunshine.
Discover vibrant coral reefs and marine life just off the shores of Key West.
Witness breathtaking sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico on a memorable cruise.
Dive into the crystal-clear waters of Key West with unforgettable swimming experiences.
Discover the charm of Key West through engaging walking tours.
Explore Key West's stunning waters with exciting snorkeling, sunset cruises, and more.
