Car Rentals in Kelleys Island
Save up to 70% on car rentals in Kelleys Island. TopTours partners with Discover Cars so you get clear prices, no hidden fees, and free cancellation. Compare deals from 1,000+ companies and find the perfect rental for your trip.
Rated Excellent · 252,000+ reviews · 1,000+ brands · Award-winning service
Cars you might rent in Kelleys Island
Whether you need an economy car, SUV, convertible, or minivan—compare Kelleys Island car rental deals for every vehicle type. Discover Cars shows you all options in one place so you can book the right car at the best price.
Explore Kelleys Island by car
Rent a car and discover Kelleys Island's top sights at your own pace—from beaches and parks to historic towns and scenic lookouts.
- Marvel at the Kelleys Island Glacial Grooves State Memorial, showcasing ancient ice-carved rock formations unlike anywhere else.
- Explore the Kelleys Island State Park, offering beautiful beaches, hiking trails, and stunning views of Lake Erie.
- Rent a golf cart or bicycle to easily explore the island's quaint streets and scenic byways, a favorite local way to get around.
- Visit the Kelleys Island Historical Museum to uncover the island's fascinating past, from quarrying to Prohibition.
- Hike or bike to the North Shore Lake Erie Nature & Wildlife Preserve for incredible birdwatching and unspoiled island landscapes.
- Enjoy a fresh perch or walleye dinner at one of the many waterfront restaurants for an authentic taste of Kelleys Island.
We compare car rental prices, you save
Discover Cars is a leader in online car rental bookings. They compare deals from 1,000+ companies so you can choose the best option for your trip to Kelleys Island. Many sites hide fees—Discover Cars includes mandatory fees, taxes, and extras in the quoted price, so there are no surprises at the rental desk.
TopTours partners with Discover Cars to help you find the perfect rental. Because they negotiate with car rental companies in bulk, they often secure lower prices for you.
Award-winning service
- · World Travel Tech Awards – World's Best Car Rental Booking Website 2025
- · Magellan Awards Gold Winner 2025
- · FT 1000: Europe's Fastest Growing Companies – Top 300 (2025)
How to find a great deal
- Book early — Prices often rise closer to your trip. You can usually change or cancel for free up to 48 hours before pickup.
- Check reviews — See what previous renters say. A supplier score of 8 or higher is a good sign.
- Mind the deposit — You’ll leave a deposit at pickup. Check rental conditions so you have enough credit.
- Fuel & mileage — Know what’s included to avoid extra fees.
What you need to pick up the car
Driver's license
A valid license in the name of the main driver.
Identification
A passport or other ID, especially when renting abroad.
Credit card
In the main driver’s name, with enough funds for the rental and deposit.
Voucher
A printed or e-voucher from your booking confirmation.