La Siciliana

November 9, 2025

TLDR; Olive Garden is better, don’t bother with this place and go elsewhere. We walked in on a Saturday night. Several open tables and there was no one ahead of us but it still took several minutes to be seated. Water and bread service came shortly thereafter. This is where things went south. The olive oil with the bread is low quality and has a bad aftertaste. It took ~10 minutes from being seated for our order to be taken which was disappointing given how the restaurant was less than 3/4 full. We ordered a salad to start, a chicken alla Rita, and a linguini Alfredo with chicken. It took in excess of 25 minutes for the main dishes to arrive (total now >35 minutes from walking in). We never did receive the salad to start. When the food arrived, the chicken alla Rita was legitimately cold. Barely room temperature and clearly not fresh. The pesto pasta that accompanied it was very hot and quite tasty. If the chicken had been even lukewarm, it would have been a wonderful dish. The Alfredo sauce for the linguini had the consistency and taste of warm milk. There was no flavor and it was too thin to adequately stick to the noodles. This is why this place deserves a 1 star. We brought our concerns to the waitress who immediately dismissed everything. Said that sometimes timing in the kitchen gets off and that’s why the chicken is cold (well obviously there’s a timing issue..), the Alfredo sauce is flavorless and thin because they “can’t put kilos of cheese in the sauce in the kitchen because they don’t know diner’s preferences,” and then asked what salad we ordered so she could remove it from the bill (she was the one who took the order so she should know what kind of salad it was). No apology at all, no offer to remake or even reheat the chicken, and in general just gaslit us as if this was our first time ever eating Italian food. Unreal. I’m married to an Italian and travel nearly 2 weeks every month for work. I’ve tried many, many, many Italian restaurants and dishes and this place ranks as one of the worst, in both food and service. Stay away.

August 10, 2025

No words can describe how magical the food taste here. It’s as authentic as it can be. The owners and staff are so kind and ready to please. Thank you, La Siciliana..

June 8, 2025

Ordered lasagna bolognese and chicken parmesan. The lasagna consisted of 4 layers of pasta with little to nothing else that you would expect in a lasagna (refer to the photo). The chicken parmesan had a larger portion size but lacked flavor and sauce. The price for the amount, quality, and flavor of the food doesn't make sense...it's very overpriced . I will not order again and I wouldn't recommend it

June 24, 2025

I had one of the worst meals in my life here. I was served 2, 1 mm thick slices of dry, tough inedible grilled chicken topped with 2 tablespoons of picatta sauce, and a mountain of dry slightly undercooked (not al dented, undercooked) garlic noodles. When the server finally came back she asked if I wasn't hungry and I told her the chicken was dry and tough. Her response was chicken is hard to cook and some people like it well done. Took my plate missing 4 bites and charged me for it. I can understand a kitchen sending out poorly cooked food occasionally, but can't excuse full on bad service. No wonder they closed early and were slow on a Saturday night. Go elsewhere.

November 17, 2024

Excellent little Italian restaurant. Lady who runs it is funny and personable and was our server for the evening. I had the Italian Sausage, which was very tasty. My wife, who is celiac, loved the gluten-free gnocchi with mushrooms and alfredo (they also have fresh gluten-free fettuccine). They also have a decent but abbreviated Italian wine selection; the prices for which were very reasonable. All told we got out for ~$200 with tip for 4 people, which included 4 entrées plus 2 bottles of wine; not bad!