Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop

August 30, 2025

This is not just a simple bread shop. They offer hearty loaves, breakfast options, and desserts that actually feel worth it. The sausage and pepper focaccias are great, the breakfast sandwiches are incredible. The pecan and currant bread has a solid balance of sweet and nutty that works perfectly toasted with butter. Fire Island Bakery has a strong presence the moment you step inside. The space is clean, welcoming, and filled with the smell of fresh bread and pastries coming straight out of the ovens. One of the best parts is being able to see the bakers working in the background. Watching the process gives the place a sense of authenticity and you know the food is being made with care. On the sweeter side, the display case is filled with cupcakes and tarts. They are rich without being over the top and each one feels like it has been crafted with intention. Fire Island Bakery delivers consistency and quality across the board. Whether you want something quick with your morning coffee or you are stocking up on bread for the week, it is a spot that wont disappoint.

July 17, 2025

This bakery truly delivers on its promise of quality. The pastries were incredibly fresh, and we loved that they use local organic flour and seasonal produce — you can really taste the difference! We tried a scone that was absolutely delicious — not overly sweet, just the right balance, and baked to perfection. It’s clear that a lot of care goes into each item. While it’s a little on the pricey side, the quality and ingredients make it well worth the treat. Highly recommend for anyone who appreciates thoughtfully made baked goods!

September 19, 2025

Great spot for breakfast, but the full breakfast menu is only available Wednesday through Sunday. On other days, they serve pastries and sandwiches. We tried the salmon sandwich, and it was delicious.

August 21, 2025

A short blocks walk from the Mariot to get delicious freshly prepared or baked treats and bread as well as sparkling drinks. Within the K Street Market building there's a great coffee and plants! Shop and a veggies and smoothies shop.

May 25, 2025

Atmosphere – 3 stars The bakeshop has a cozy, rustic vibe but feels a bit cramped, especially when it’s busy—which seems to be most of the time. There are a few tables available, but I found the seating uncomfortable and the cleanliness lacking. There were noticeable crumbs on both the floor and tables, which took away from the overall experience. Service – 3 stars It’s a walk-up counter style setup, and while the staff was polite and moved fairly efficiently, there wasn’t much in terms of personal engagement. I asked if they had white milk, and they looked at me like I was speaking a foreign language. After a bit of confusion, they finally figured out what I meant and told me I could get milk from the nearby coffee stand. Not rude, just a little unpolished. Food – 4 stars I got a ham and cheese sandwich that was pretty good—the bread was especially fresh. I also tried a chocolate chip cookie, which was really good. I added a blueberry crème cupcake to the mix—it was tasty, but a little hard to eat since it was chilled and the frosting was firm, almost brittle, and broke apart. Overall, the quality of the baked goods was solid, but the pricing felt a bit steep for what you get. Not sure if I’d go out of my way to return.