American
Hole In The Wall - FiDi
Discover Hole In The Wall - FiDi in NYC, boasting a 4.8-star rating. Enjoy delicious brunch and breakfast in a vibrant atmosphere. Reserve your table today!
4.8$$American
View RestaurantVia Carota
Nestled in the heart of the West Village, this esteemed Italian eatery offers a truly charming dining experience. With a commendable 4.4/5 rating, it's a popular spot for those seeking thoughtful, vegetable-forward plates and comforting, rustic pastas. The ambience is undeniably elegant, providing a lovely backdrop for a meal. While the execution can sometimes vary, and wait times can be lengthy, the overall experience is a pleasant one. Diners appreciate the sophisticated atmosphere and the unique approach to Italian cuisine, making it a noteworthy destination for an authentic taste of the city. Outdoor seating and cocktails are available, and reservations are recommended.
Italian•$$$•4.4(3,091)•New York City
Nestled in the heart of the West Village, this esteemed Italian eatery offers a truly charming dining experience. With a commendable 4.4/5 rating, it's a popular spot for those seeking thoughtful, vegetable-forward plates and comforting, rustic pastas. The ambience is undeniably elegant, providing a lovely backdrop for a meal. While the execution can sometimes vary, and wait times can be lengthy, the overall experience is a pleasant one. Diners appreciate the sophisticated atmosphere and the unique approach to Italian cuisine, making it a noteworthy destination for an authentic taste of the city. Outdoor seating and cocktails are available, and reservations are recommended.
About Via Carota
Nestled in the heart of the West Village, this esteemed Italian eatery offers a truly charming dining experience. With a commendable 4.4/5 rating, it's a popular spot for those seeking thoughtful, vegetable-forward plates and comforting, rustic pastas. The ambience is undeniably elegant, providing a lovely backdrop for a meal. While the execution can sometimes vary, and wait times can be lengthy, the overall experience is a pleasant one. Diners appreciate the sophisticated atmosphere and the unique approach to Italian cuisine, making it a noteworthy destination for an authentic taste of the city. Outdoor seating and cocktails are available, and reservations are recommended.
📊
Restaurant Analysis
Restaurant Characteristics
Formula-Based Analysis
This restaurant has been analyzed using our formula-based system to help you understand its key features and match it with your dining preferences.
💰Price Range
Upscale
Price Range (Upscale)
Upscale dining ($$$) - Fine dining with premium prices
🕐Meal Time
dinner
Meal Time (dinner)
This restaurant primarily serves dinner. Based on opening hours.
👥Group Size
Groups Welcome
Group Size (Groups Welcome)
Welcomes large groups and families. Great for group dining.
🎭Atmosphere
Outdoor
Atmosphere (Outdoor)
Al fresco dining with outdoor seating
🍽️Dining Style
Flexible
Dining Style (Flexible)
Flexible options. Reservations available but not required.
✨Features & Amenities
Outdoor Seating
Cocktails
Beer
Wine
+3 more
Features & Amenities
This restaurant offers: Outdoor Seating, Cocktails, Beer, Wine, Coffee, Groups Welcome, Reservations
Why Travelers Love Via Carota
Sourced from recent guest feedback and verified reviews.
4.4 / 5.0(3,091 reviews)
Via Carota remains one of the West Village’s most charming dining rooms, but the experience doesn’t always match the legend. The vegetable-forward plates are thoughtful, the pastas rustic and comforting, and the ambience undeniably elegant. Yet the execution can be uneven: seasoning varies from dish to dish, and wait times stretch long even with a reservation. Service feels more “hands-off” than attentive. A pleasant meal overall, but the hype sets expectations higher than the kitchen consistently delivers. Via Carota is a NYC staple. No frills space, super cozy, great for a simple but delicious italian meal. All the appetizers were good and the quality of the produce stands out in all of them. We loved the tomato cucumber salad and the burrata, as well as the sourdough bread to go along. Carbonara pasta is the star of the show, but don't sleep on the desserts: both the tiramisu and the strawberries with zabaione were great. Maybe not worth waiting in line for, but if you see a reservation spot open up, then snag it for sure. Wanted to try this place for over a year and finally got to shortly before halloweekend - started waiting in line right at 5 pm and got a table by the windows shortly after. Loved the rustic vibes here and our server gave us a very thorough rundown of the weekly and monthly specials. The mushroom and truffle pasta was interesting, but not as flavorful as I thought it would be. I really liked the veggie soup and broccoli. We got a special dessert with pear, red wine and creme and it wasn’t great, but glad we tried it anyway!
Find the Restaurant
Where to Find Them
Opening Hours
Open Now
Monday11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Tuesday11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Thursday11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Friday10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Recent Reviews
Baydoun B.
November 11, 2025
Via Carota remains one of the West Village’s most charming dining rooms, but the experience doesn’t always match the legend. The vegetable-forward plates are thoughtful, the pastas rustic and comforting, and the ambience undeniably elegant. Yet the execution can be uneven: seasoning varies from dish to dish, and wait times stretch long even with a reservation. Service feels more “hands-off” than attentive. A pleasant meal overall, but the hype sets expectations higher than the kitchen consistently delivers.
Bianca R.
October 12, 2025
Via Carota is a NYC staple. No frills space, super cozy, great for a simple but delicious italian meal. All the appetizers were good and the quality of the produce stands out in all of them. We loved the tomato cucumber salad and the burrata, as well as the sourdough bread to go along. Carbonara pasta is the star of the show, but don't sleep on the desserts: both the tiramisu and the strawberries with zabaione were great. Maybe not worth waiting in line for, but if you see a reservation spot open up, then snag it for sure.
Shar G.
November 4, 2025
Wanted to try this place for over a year and finally got to shortly before halloweekend - started waiting in line right at 5 pm and got a table by the windows shortly after. Loved the rustic vibes here and our server gave us a very thorough rundown of the weekly and monthly specials. The mushroom and truffle pasta was interesting, but not as flavorful as I thought it would be. I really liked the veggie soup and broccoli. We got a special dessert with pear, red wine and creme and it wasn’t great, but glad we tried it anyway!
Fiona D.
August 12, 2025
I could never find a reservation here but it was good to know to go right at opening time for lunch. We were a party of 4 and didn’t have to wait at all. The food definitely lived up to the hype. Everything we ordered was delicious and well made! We ordered a bunch of stuff to share and none of us had any complaints. The only thing I was surprised about was the size of my grilled octopus. It was the tiniest piece and barely big enough to be counted as an entree. Regardless, we all had a great time and would def be back
Kat N.
October 10, 2025
Definitely come for the pasta! I don't usually favor the parpardelle but the parpardelle ragu was delicious - paper thin ribbons of house made pasta really hit the spot. I got in easily as a walk-in solo diner at the bar on a weeknight at 6:45pm. Reservations are hard to come by.
What to Expect
Features and amenities that make Via Carota special
Outdoor Seating
Cocktails
Beer
Wine
Coffee
Groups Welcome
Reservations
Practical Information
Everything you need to know before you visit
Payment Options
Credit Cards
Debit Cards
NFC/Contactless
Parking
Free Street Parking
Paid Parking Lot
Paid Street Parking
Accessibility
Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
Wheelchair Accessible Seating
Other Popular Restaurants in New York City
Build your own culinary trail—save these spots for future nights out in New York City.
American
The Dead Rabbit
Experience acclaimed Irish pub fare and cocktails in NYC. A 4.7-star gem offering vibrant vibes and memorable dishes. Discover why locals rave.
4.7$$American · European
View RestaurantAmerican
Manhatta
Experience elevated American dining at this 4.7-star New York City restaurant. Discover innovative cuisine and exceptional service. Reserve your table.
4.7$$$$American · Fusion
View RestaurantEuropean
Petite Boucherie
Experience a charming Parisian-inspired bistro in NYC, rated 4.7 stars. Savor delightful French fare and enjoy a cozy atmosphere. Reserve your table today.
4.7$$European
View RestaurantAmerican
Gramercy Tavern
Experience fine dining in NYC at this acclaimed American restaurant, rated 4.6 stars. Discover exceptional cuisine and a vibrant atmosphere. Reserve your table.
4.6$$$$American
View RestaurantEuropean
La Grande Boucherie
Experience a 4.6-star French dining gem in NYC. Discover exquisite cuisine, a beautiful setting, and excellent service. Book your table today!
4.6$$European · Steakhouse & Grill
View RestaurantSeafood
Le Bernardin
Experience NYC's top French seafood at Le Bernardin. Enjoy exquisite dishes with a 4.6/5 rating. Book your unforgettable dining experience today.
4.6$$$$Seafood · European
View RestaurantEuropean
La Parisienne
Experience a charming French brunch in NYC. Enjoy delicious food and coffee at this cozy spot, rated 4.6 stars. Perfect for a delightful meal.
4.6$$European
View RestaurantSeafood
1803 NYC
Experience 1803 NYC, a highly-rated 4.5-star restaurant in New York City. Discover delicious brunch and seafood dishes. Reservations recommended.
4.5$$Seafood · American
View RestaurantSteakhouse & Grill
Harry's
Experience a 4.5-star New York City restaurant offering classic dishes and cocktails in a sophisticated atmosphere. Perfect for dates or business. Reservations recommended.
4.5$$$Steakhouse & Grill · American
View RestaurantEuropean
Minetta Tavern
Experience a 4.5-star New York City gem offering classic French fare and renowned burgers. Discover a lively atmosphere and exceptional service. Book your table.
4.5$$$European · American
View RestaurantAmerican
Fraunces Tavern
Experience historic American dining in New York City at Fraunces Tavern. Enjoy a 4.5-star experience with generous portions and charming ambiance. Reserve your table today!
4.5$$American · Steakhouse & Grill
View RestaurantCaribbean & Latin
Coppelia
Experience a vibrant Cuban diner in NYC with a 4.4 rating. Savor delicious brunch, burgers, and cocktails. Discover this unique spot for a memorable meal.
4.4$$Caribbean & Latin
View RestaurantAmerican
abc kitchen
Dine at a highly-rated NYC American restaurant, celebrated for its vibrant atmosphere and creative dishes. Enjoy a memorable meal with a 4.4/5 star rating. Reserve your table today.
4.4$$$American · Fusion
View RestaurantCaribbean & Latin
Tatiana by Kwame Onwuachi
Experience exceptional dining at Tatiana by Kwame Onwuachi in NYC. This acclaimed restaurant, with a 4.3-star rating, offers a memorable culinary journey. Discover its vibrant atmosphere and exquisite flavors.
4.3$$$$Caribbean & Latin · Fusion
View RestaurantAmerican
Jams
Discover a charming NYC restaurant with a 4.2-star rating. Enjoy delicious brunch, cocktails, and a vibrant atmosphere. Reservable and great for groups.
4.2$$$American
View RestaurantItalian
Eataly
Discover authentic Italian cuisine at NYC's renowned food hall. Experience fresh pasta, pizza, and more. Enjoy live music and cocktails. Rated 4.2 stars. Visit Eataly today!
4.2$$Italian
View RestaurantPlan Your New York City Trip
From transportation to stays, we help you build a complete itinerary around this must-visit restaurant in New York City.
Transportation Tips
Excellent public transportation with subway, buses, and trains. Walking is perfect for exploring neighborhoods, and taxis/Uber are readily available.
Related Travel Guides for New York City
Explore comprehensive guides to plan your perfect trip, including food tours, cultural experiences, and more.
New York City Airport Transfers
Planning your arrival in New York City? Travelers can easily compare and book a range of airport transfer options to and from John F. Kennedy International Airport, LaGuardia Airport, and Newark Liberty International Airport. Whether you prefer shared shuttles or private car services, numerous providers offer convenient ways to reach your destination.
Read Guide
New York City Architecture Tours
Explore iconic skyscrapers, Art Deco masterpieces, and historic buildings!
Read Guide
NYC Bike Tours: Explore on Two Wheels
Discover the best bike tours in New York City and see the sights.
Read Guide
New York City Broadway Shows
Experience world-famous theater: Hamilton, Wicked, Lion King, and more!
Read Guide
New York City Central Park Tours
Explore NYC's iconic urban oasis with 843 acres of green space!
Read Guide
NYC Comedy Show Adventures
Laugh your heart out with hilarious stand-up and improv comedy shows in NYC!
Read Guide
NYC Day Cruises: City Views & Fresh Air
Discover stunning NYC sights from the water with unforgettable day cruise experiences.
Read Guide
NYC Day Trip Adventures
Explore beyond the city with unforgettable day trips from New York City!
Read Guide
NYC Dessert Tour Delights
Indulge your sweet tooth and discover the best desserts NYC has to offer!
Read Guide
NYC: Top Tours, Excellent Quality
Discover New York City with exceptional tours that guarantee memorable experiences.
Read Guide
Family Shows: NYC Adventures
Enjoy captivating performances perfect for creating lasting memories with your family in NYC!
Read Guide
New York City Food & Culture Tours
Taste authentic NYC: pizza, bagels, street food, and global cuisines!
Read Guide
NYC Food & Drink Adventures
Savor the best eats and drinks the city has to offer with these culinary experiences.
Read Guide
NYC Half-Day Tours: Quick City Adventures
Explore New York City's highlights in a fun and efficient half-day experience.
Read Guide
NYC Tours with Animals
Discover unique NYC experiences with animals, from zoos to animal encounters.
Read Guide
NYC Adventures for Kids
Discover fun and exciting kid-friendly tours perfect for families exploring New York City.
Read Guide
NYC Limousine Transfers
Arrive in style and comfort with seamless limousine transfers across New York City.
Read Guide
New York City Museum Tours
Explore world-class museums: MET, MoMA, Natural History, and more!
Read Guide
NYC Music Tour Guide
Explore New York City's vibrant music scene with a curated selection of tours.
Read Guide
NYC Nature & Wildlife Tours
Discover the wild side of the city with these immersive nature and wildlife experiences.
Read Guide
NYC Nature Walks: Escape the Concrete
Discover the lush green spaces and hidden natural beauty of New York City.
Read Guide
NYC Overnight Adventures
Explore the city that never sleeps with an unforgettable overnight experience.
Read Guide
NYC Pedicab Tours
Explore New York City's iconic sights with a relaxing and unique pedicab experience.
Read Guide
NYC Port Pickup Tours
Seamless transportation from the port to your hotel or desired destination.
Read Guide
NYC: Private & Luxurious Experiences
Indulge in exclusive, personalized tours of New York City with top-tier service.
Read Guide
NYC Private Driver Experiences
Explore New York City with ease and comfort in a private vehicle.
Read Guide
Private NYC Sightseeing Tours
Explore New York City with personalized, exclusive, and unforgettable private tours.
Read Guide
NYC Restaurant Tours
Discover the diverse culinary scene of New York City with curated dining experiences.
Read Guide
Romantic NYC Tours
Discover the magic of New York City with enchanting and intimate experiences.
Read Guide
NYC Shows: Broadway & Beyond
Discover the magic of live performances with shows ranging from Broadway hits to Off-Broadway gems.
Read Guide
NYC Theater Show Tours
Experience the magic of Broadway and off-Broadway with unforgettable theater tours.
Read Guide
New York City Times Square Tours
Experience the Crossroads of the World with dazzling billboards and NYC energy!
Read Guide
NYC TV Tours: See Your Favorite Shows!
Explore iconic filming locations and behind-the-scenes secrets from your favorite TV shows.
Read Guide
NYC Walking Tour Guide
Discover the best walking tours in New York City with ease.
Read Guide
NYC Water Tours: Explore by Sea!
Discover New York City's iconic landmarks and stunning skyline from the water.
Read Guide
NYC Zombie Adventure
Explore NYC with a thrilling zombie twist, from themed experiences to survival games.
Read Guide